You asked if a landlord can refuse Section 8 in New York State. The short answer, and the one that will save you a ton of heartburn, is this: Generally, no.
It’s an open-and-shut case, folks. Landlords in New York State, for the most part, cannot legally refuse a potential tenant just because they are using a Section 8 Housing Choice Voucher or any other form of legal rental assistance. Why? Because the Empire State stepped up and made this practice, known as "source of income discrimination," illegal statewide. It's a huge deal, and it means that voucher holders are finally getting a fair shake when apartment hunting.
But hey, you didn't come here for the short answer, did you? You came for the whole enchilada—the deep dive, the nitty-gritty, the stuff that makes your head spin but is totally necessary to know. So, let's buckle up and cruise through the wild world of New York's anti-discrimination housing laws. This is going to be a fun ride! 🗽
Step 1: 🧐 Understanding the Law: The "Source of Income" Smackdown
In 2019, New York State decided to stop playing games and amended the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL). This amendment was a total game-changer, making it crystal clear that your "lawful source of income" is a protected class.
 |
| Can A Landlord Refuse Section 8 In New York State |
1.1. What's a "Lawful Source of Income," Anyway?
Imagine you're trying to buy a sweet slice of pizza. It doesn't matter if you're paying with a twenty-dollar bill, a debit card, or a gift certificate; the pizza joint still has to take your dough! In the housing world, the "dough" is your income, and the law says how you get it shouldn't matter if it's legal.
Federal Housing Vouchers: Hello, Section 8! This is the big one. Refusing a tenant just because they have a Section 8 voucher is a major no-no.
Other Public Assistance: We're talking about things like Social Security Income (SSI), public assistance (like Temporary Assistance for Needy Families or Safety Net Assistance), or even specific rental subsidies like CityFHEPS.
Alimony and Child Support: Money from an ex or for the kids? If it's legally yours, it counts and is protected.
Veterans' Benefits: Thank you for your service—and yes, that income is protected, too.
So, when a landlord sees that Section 8 voucher, they're supposed to treat it just like a direct deposit from a swanky corporate job. They're basically supposed to say, "Sweet, guaranteed money from the government!" instead of slamming the door in your face.
Step 2: 🙅♀️ What Landlords Absolutely Cannot Do
It's not just about a flat-out refusal. Landlords are crafty—they've been trying to dodge these rules for ages. The NYSHRL shuts down their sneaky tactics, too. This is where it gets real.
Tip: Reading on mobile? Zoom in for better comfort.
2.1. The Outright Ban
The law makes it illegal for an owner, landlord, management company, or broker to:
Refuse to Rent: Duh. The obvious one. They can't just say, "Nah, we don't do Section 8." That’s a one-way ticket to a discrimination complaint.
Advertise Discrimination: No more posting listings that scream, "NO SECTION 8," "NO DSS," or “Voucher-free zone only!” Those listings are now a beacon for the state's Civil Rights Bureau.
2.2. The Sneaky Ban (A.K.A. "Different Strokes for Different Folks")
This is the subtle, under-the-radar stuff that makes this a serious issue. A landlord can't give you the runaround, either. This includes:
Tougher Screening Standards: If they demand a higher credit score or more employment history from you, a voucher holder, than they do from a non-voucher applicant, they’re breaking the law. They have to use the same criteria for everyone.
"The Rent is Too High" Trick: The apartment might be listed at a reasonable rent, but suddenly, when they see your voucher, they claim the unit is only available for a higher, non-subsidized price. Totally illegal.
Unequal Terms: Giving you a shorter lease, or denying you access to amenities (like the roof deck or the fancy gym) because of your voucher? Forget about it. You’re a regular tenant with all the regular rights.
Step 3: ⚖️ A Note on NYC vs. The Rest of New York
New York City—the Big Apple—often has its own extra rules, and in this case, it was ahead of the curve.
3.1. NYC’s OG Rule
Source of income discrimination has been illegal in NYC since 2008. That means they’ve been enforcing this for over a decade. The NYC Commission on Human Rights is legendary for its aggressive investigation and prosecution of these cases, and the penalties can be steep. They are not messing around.
Tip: Don’t skip the small notes — they often matter.
3.2. The Statewide Harmony
When the state law was amended in 2019, it basically took the NYC model and rolled it out for every other county and city in New York, from Buffalo to Long Island. This created a uniform shield for tenants everywhere, which is awesome.
Step 4: 🚨 The Catch—When a Landlord Can (Kind of) Say No
While a landlord cannot refuse you simply because you have a Section 8 voucher, they still have the right to run a legitimate tenant screening. This is the critical part you need to understand.
 |
4.1. The Legal Screening Process
A landlord can still legally deny your application for the same, non-discriminatory reasons they would deny a cash-paying tenant. This might include:
Bad Credit/Financial History: If your non-subsidy portion of the rent is high and your credit score suggests you can't pay it, a denial might be legitimate. However, they must count your voucher as guaranteed income.
Prior Evictions: A history of being evicted for non-lease compliance (like damaging the property or engaging in illegal activity) is a valid reason for denial.
Criminal History: An applicant can be denied for certain criminal convictions, provided the policy is applied consistently and does not have a discriminatory impact.
4.2. The HQS Headache: Housing Quality Standards
This is the big sticky wicket. For a Section 8 payment to kick in, the rental unit must pass an inspection by the Public Housing Agency (PHA). This is called meeting the Housing Quality Standards (HQS). If the place is a total dump—we’re talking no smoke detectors, busted windows, or a roof that's seen better days—it will fail the inspection.
QuickTip: Slow down if the pace feels too fast.
The Landlord's Responsibility: The landlord has to make the repairs. If they refuse to fix the place up to pass HQS, they technically aren't rejecting you, they are rejecting the conditions of the program. However, a pattern of perpetually refusing to make minor, reasonable repairs to avoid the Section 8 process can, and often is, seen as source of income discrimination. It's a fine line!
Step 5: 🥊 You Got Rejected! Now What? (A.K.A. Fighting the Power)
If you feel like you've been unfairly denied an apartment simply because of your Section 8 voucher, you’ve got options—and they have teeth!
5.1. The Complaint Hotline
Your first move is to file a complaint. You can reach out to the state or local enforcement agencies. This is how you sic the legal eagles on the landlord.
New York State Division of Human Rights (DHR): This is the main state agency. Filing a complaint is free, and they will investigate your claim.
NYC Commission on Human Rights (CCHR): If you're in the five boroughs, these are your guys. They are known for their aggressive enforcement.
5.2. Gathering the Proof
You need to be a savvy investigator. Discrimination is subtle, so get your ducks in a row:
Written Evidence: Keep all emails, texts, or applications. Did a listing say, "No Vouchers"? Screenshot it! Did the landlord send an email saying, "Sorry, we decided to go with a non-voucher tenant"? Bingo.
Witnesses: Did a friend call up about the unit and get told a different story than you? Did the broker say they don't take vouchers? Get their name and a written account of the conversation.
The state and city have a zero-tolerance policy. If the agencies find the landlord discriminated against you, they can slap them with massive fines and order them to pay you damages for the emotional distress and the costs of your housing search.
FAQ Questions and Answers
Tip: Read carefully — skimming skips meaning.
How can a landlord legally deny a Section 8 applicant in New York?
A landlord can legally deny a Section 8 applicant for the same, non-discriminatory reasons they would deny any other tenant, such as a poor credit history (for the tenant's share of the rent), a history of major lease violations, or a verifiable, recent history of damaging property in previous rentals. They must apply the same screening criteria to all applicants.
How do I report a New York landlord for refusing to accept my Section 8 voucher?
You should file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights (DHR) or, if you live in the five boroughs, the NYC Commission on Human Rights (CCHR). These agencies investigate claims of source of income discrimination at no cost to you.
What happens if the apartment doesn't pass the initial Section 8 inspection?
If the unit fails the initial Housing Quality Standards (HQS) inspection, the landlord must make the necessary repairs to bring the unit up to federal safety and habitability standards. If the landlord refuses to make simple, required repairs and pulls the listing, it may be interpreted as a form of illegal source of income discrimination.
Does a landlord have to renew a Section 8 tenant's lease?
Yes, a landlord in New York must offer a renewal lease to a Section 8 tenant under the same conditions as any other tenant, unless they have a legal, non-discriminatory reason not to, such as a documented, repeated violation of the lease terms by the tenant. They cannot refuse to renew because of the voucher.
Can a landlord charge a higher rent to a Section 8 tenant?
No. A landlord must offer the unit at the same rent they offer to non-subsidized tenants. Furthermore, the total rent must be approved by the Public Housing Agency (PHA) as "rent reasonable" and cannot exceed the established payment standard for that area. Charging different rates based on the source of income is a clear violation of the NYSHRL.
 |
